Safer Places NB

Category: legal case studies

  • A real story of workplace sexual harassment– the convenience store cashier

    A real story of workplace sexual harassment– the convenience store cashier

    Facts – Ms. J worked as a cashier at a store owned by Mr. T. During Ms. J’s shifts, Mr. T would often come to the store and stay for her entire shift. While she was working, Mr. T would make jokes that were sexual in nature and tease her about being sexually active. Mr. T would also identify different parts of Ms. J’s body and disclose to her what he would do to them if he had the chance. After a series of uncomfortable comments, Ms. J decided to address Mr. T and tell him that she did not appreciate the comments he was making. During this conversation, Mr. T offered Ms. J money to perform sexual favours. When Ms. J declined, Mr. T began calling her rude nicknames which created a hostile relationship. When male customers would come to the store, Mr. T would accuse Ms. J of sleeping with them. 

    Eventually, Mr. T terminated Ms. J’s employment after being rejected. After she was terminated, and had filed the complaint, Mr. T began trespassing at her residence and observing her in the middle of the night. 

    Analysis – The British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal first discussed the risk that women face of violence and harassment based on gender or sex, and further, the abuse of power and gendered dynamics that sexual harassment entails. Ms. J experienced adverse treatment and impacts throughout her employment on the basis of her gender, which began when she was subjected to sexualized comments, and continued when the respondent sexually propositioned her.

    Takeaway – Employers are not allowed to retaliate against employees after the employee has disclosed to them that their behaviour makes them feel uncomfortable. Here, the tribunal makes an important distinct focus on the gendered power dynamics between a young woman employee and middle-aged male boss. Remedies – The Tribunal made two awards of monetary compensation to the complainant. For lost wages, the Tribunal awarded $53, 916.72. For injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect the Tribunal made an award of $45,000.00.

    Ms. K v Deep Creek Store and another, 2021 BCHRT 158